A customer disputes transactions, the bank refunds them, and then the bank sues the customer in local police court for willful misconduct or gross negligence. Between August and October 2026, Chile's Supreme Court held again that the bank carries the burden of proving that negligence, and spelled out what falls short. The same rulings show when the bank does win.

On October 29, Chile’s judiciary released a figure that captures where things stand. The local police court in San Carlos, a town in the Ñuble region, received 90 claims under Law No. 20,009 (Ley N° 20.009), Chile’s Fraud Law, through 2025: 6 in 2022, 13 in 2023, 16 in 2024 and 55 in 2025. Of those 90, 82 were dismissed because the bank could not prove willful misconduct or gross negligence by the customer, 5 ended in a settlement, and the bank prevailed in only 3.

One court is a small sample, but the figure lines up with what the Supreme Court has been saying. In two rulings handed down between August and October of this year, the Court held again that the bank must prove the customer’s gross negligence, and spelled out what does not meet that bar: clicking a link, entering a code, or falling for a well-built scam.

This analysis walks through those rulings and a recent one from the Santiago Court of Appeals, explains how these cases reach the Supreme Court, and dwells on the part that usually gets left out: the cases banks win. The first steps after a fraud (notice to the bank, the police report, the statutory refund deadlines) are covered in our guide to what to do after bank fraud in Chile.

What kind of lawsuit is this?

The pattern is always the same. A customer disputes transactions on an account or card, notifies the bank and files a claim, and the bank refunds within the statutory deadlines. Then, if it believes there was willful misconduct or gross negligence, the bank sues in the local police court, a municipal court that hears consumer claims and minor infractions, asking it to declare that negligence and order the refund repaid.

The victim thus becomes the defendant, and the question is no longer whether there was fraud, but whether the customer was so careless that the law shifts the loss onto them.

What counts as gross negligence under Chilean law?

Article 44 of the Civil Code (Código Civil) defines it as failing to manage another’s affairs “with the care that even negligent and imprudent people usually take in their own affairs” (in free translation). The same article adds that, in civil matters, this degree of negligence is equivalent to willful misconduct. The Supreme Court restated the point in Rol No. 14.463-2026 (seventh recital).

The yardstick, then, is not the careful customer but the careless one: gross negligence means skipping even the minimal care a negligent person takes in their own affairs. A mistake, or something that could have been handled better in hindsight, does not qualify.

That standard is now in play in Congress. As introduced, the capital markets reform bill known as MK4 would have lowered it to slight negligence, letting banks off the hook by proving ordinary carelessness. According to the official notice of October 27 transmitting the approved text, the Chamber of Deputies sent the bill to the Senate without that change. The Financial Market Commission (CMF) had called the change a priority, so it may come back as an amendment.

Who has to prove it?

The bank. This is the first holding in both Supreme Court rulings, and everything else follows from it.

The Court held that in fraud cases the rules on burden of proof “operate differently from the general rules,” and that the issuer is released from the refund only if it proves the user’s willful misconduct or gross negligence (Rol No. 55.219-2025, seventh recital; Rol No. 14.463-2026, sixth recital; our translation). It is not for the customer to prove that they were diligent.

The second piece is how a court reads what the customer says. In the Banco Santander case, the Santiago Court of Appeals had found negligence based solely on the customer’s admission of clicking a link, ignoring the customer’s denial of having handed over any passwords or the security grid card. In the Supreme Court’s words, that produced “a reversal of the burden of proof to the detriment of the account holder” (Rol No. 55.219-2025, ninth to eleventh recitals; our translation). In the Banco Itaú case, it criticized a “partial assessment” of the customer’s testimony that took into account “only the part that harms her” (Rol No. 14.463-2026, sixth recital; our translation).

The practical upshot is simple: the customer’s account is weighed as a whole. A judge cannot keep the sentence that incriminates and discard the one that exonerates.

Not by itself. The two Supreme Court rulings make the point from different directions.

The link (Banco Santander). The customer clicked a link in a text message (smishing) but, by their own account, handed over neither passwords nor the security grid card. Six transfers totaling CLP 2,098,162 then went out to a new payee. The Colina local police court dismissed the bank’s claim; the Santiago Court of Appeals reversed. On October 6, 2026, the Supreme Court granted the customer’s recurso de queja, a disciplinary appeal against the appellate judges, vacated their judgment and reinstated the trial court’s ruling.

The code (Banco Itaú). The customer fell for a phone scam (vishing) and entered the code the fraudsters sent her. The trial court ordered her to pay CLP 1,168,252 back to the bank, and the Santiago Court of Appeals affirmed. On August 31, 2026, the Supreme Court denied the queja but set the judgment aside on its own motion and dismissed the claim. Its reasoning was that the scheme “gives the transaction an appearance of normality” and that this kind of fraud “does not appear to have been specifically brought to the attention of the bank’s customers”; on that basis the evidence of gross negligence was too thin (seventh recital; our translation). Justice Mireya López and Pía Tavolari, a practicing lawyer sitting on the panel as an abogada integrante, dissented from the decision to act on the Court’s own motion.

That gives the third principle: a sophisticated scam does not amount to gross negligence by the user, particularly where the bank never warned its customers about that scheme. The customer’s involvement says little, since victims of deception almost always take part in the transaction; what matters is whether they acted without even minimal care.

If the customer took no part at all, because the SIM card was swapped and the codes went straight to the fraudster, different rules apply and a second party may be liable; we cover that in They took the SIM and emptied the account.

What if the bank’s fraud monitoring missed the transfers?

Its case gets weaker. The bank’s duty of security is part of the analysis, even though the bank is the one that brought the lawsuit.

Article 6 of Law No. 20,009 requires issuers to run monitoring systems capable of detecting transactions that do not match the user’s usual behavior. In the Banco Santander case, six transfers went to a new payee within a very short time and the bank did nothing; it did not even have the one-time passcode sent to the customer’s phone. The Supreme Court found that the bank “failed to meet its minimum security obligation” (Rol No. 55.219-2025, twelfth recital; our translation).

The Santiago Court of Appeals applied the same logic in a ruling known so far only through press coverage. In Rol No. 305-2024, decided by its Fifth Chamber on October 19, 2026, a Banco de Chile customer disputed a charge of CLP 5,793,841. According to press coverage, including a report published on October 27, the bank’s system raised no alert despite the amount, the unfamiliar IP address and the unusual payee, all of which the bank’s own fraud report acknowledged. The court reversed the Colina local police court, which had ordered the customer to pay 35 UF (Unidades de Fomento, Chile’s inflation-indexed unit of account), dismissed the claim and ordered the bank to reverse or refund the amount above those 35 UF.

When does the bank win?

These rulings should not be read as saying the customer always wins. In San Carlos, 3 of 90 claims succeeded, and over the past two years several published judgments have gone the bank’s way. In each of them, the bank proved more than the customer’s involvement.

  • Late reporting. In Rol No. 2507-2022, reported in March 2025, the Santiago Court of Appeals reversed the First Local Police Court of Recoleta and found gross negligence by a user whose banking app had been blocked since October 26, 2021, and who took protective steps only on the 29th, without asking for the payment methods to be blocked. The court called the delay inexplicable. One judge dissented.
  • Credentials typed into a fake site, with no failure by the bank. In Rol No. 3496-2024, reported in June 2025, the Santiago Court of Appeals ruled against a user who admitted entering banking credentials on a fraudulent website, backed by a technical report that ruled out any failure in the bank’s systems.
  • Card and passwords in someone else’s hands. In Rol No. 2737-2022, reported in May 2025, gross negligence was found because the cardholder admitted that a daughter had made the transactions using the card and the passwords. In Rol No. 2133-2023, reported in July 2026, a customer was ordered to return 35 UF to Banco Santander for letting others use the card and password.

The Supreme Court itself, in February of this year, upheld a finding of gross negligence against a company for the first of three transfers, though not for the other two; we discussed it in our July guide. Gross negligence, that ruling shows, is assessed transaction by transaction.

None of these rulings departs from the Supreme Court’s line: when the bank proves a lapse beyond what any victim of deception would commit, the statute lets it recover the refund.

The rulings at a glance

Court and case numberDateBankCustomer’s conductOutcomePrinciple applied
Supreme Court, Rol No. 55.219-2025October 6, 2026SantanderClicked an SMS link; denied handing over passwords or grid cardClaim dismissedBurden on the bank; testimony weighed as a whole; monitoring failure
Supreme Court, Rol No. 14.463-2026August 31, 2026ItaúEntered a code during a phone scamClaim dismissed (set aside on the Court’s own motion)Sophisticated scam, no warning from the bank; partial reading of testimony
Santiago Court of Appeals, Rol No. 305-2024October 19, 2026Banco de ChileDisputed a charge of CLP 5,793,841Claim dismissed; bank ordered to refund the amount above 35 UFNo alert despite unusual amount, IP address and payee
Santiago Court of Appeals, Rol No. 2507-2022Reported March 2025Not disclosedReacted late after the banking app was blockedClaim grantedLate report, no request to block
Santiago Court of Appeals, Rol No. 3496-2024Reported June 2025Not disclosedEntered credentials on a fake websiteClaim grantedCredentials disclosed, no failure by the bank

We will update this table as new judgments are published.

How do these cases reach the Supreme Court?

Through a narrow door, and that explains the shape these rulings take.

Procedure in the local police courts is governed by Law No. 18,287 (Ley N° 18.287). Article 32 allows an appeal only from final judgments and from rulings that make it impossible to continue the case, within five days, and the appeal goes to the Court of Appeals. Article 38 rules out cassation in local police court proceedings.

What remains against the appellate ruling is the recurso de queja under Article 545 of the Courts Organization Code (Código Orgánico de Tribunales). It is not a third instance: it lies only against final judgments, or interlocutory rulings that end the case, where no other appeal is available, and the appellant must show that the judges committed a serious fault or abuse in issuing them. In the Banco Santander case, the Supreme Court found that reversing the burden of proof was a fault of that kind.

The same article preserves the Supreme Court’s power to act on its own motion in the exercise of its disciplinary authority. That is what happened in the Banco Itaú case: the Court denied the queja but set the order to pay aside anyway. With two dissents on precisely that point, this is an exceptional tool, and no litigant should count on it.

What should you do if your bank sues you?

  1. Respond to the lawsuit. The procedure is short and the deadlines tight. Failing to answer is the surest way to lose.
  2. Tell the whole story from the start. If the judge must weigh the customer’s account as a whole, the bank complaint, the affidavit and the police report are the foundation of the defense. They should cover everything: what the customer did, but also what was not handed over, when the problem was noticed and when the bank was told.
  3. Ask for the bank’s records. The alerts its monitoring system raised or failed to raise, the IP addresses and devices used, whether the payee was new, and whether a one-time passcode was sent and to which number. Only the bank holds that information and, as these rulings show, it often cuts against the bank.
  4. Look closely at what happened afterward. Prompt notice and a request to block carry weight. The cases banks win usually turn on exactly that.
  5. Contest each transaction separately. One transfer may be covered and another not.

A high bar, for now

These rulings guarantee no outcome: every case turns on its evidence, and banks do win. What they settle is the starting point. The bank carries the burden of proving gross negligence, the customer’s account is read in full, a well-executed deception is not inexcusable carelessness, and a bank that did not watch its own systems is poorly placed to blame the customer for not watching theirs.

Until Congress changes the standard, that is the rule these lawsuits will be decided under.


This article is general information and does not constitute legal advice on any specific matter. The statutes and case law cited should be checked in their current form before making any decision; except for the two Supreme Court rulings analyzed here, the judgments are cited as described in the press coverage that reported them. If your bank has sued you in local police court over a fraud, contact us to review your situation with our Banking Fraud practice.

Frequently asked questions

What is gross negligence in a Chilean bank fraud case?

The standard comes from Article 44 of the Civil Code: failing to manage another's affairs with the care that even negligent and imprudent people usually take in their own. It is the most serious degree of negligence and, in civil matters, the law treats it as equivalent to willful misconduct. Under Law No. 20,009 the bank is released from the refund only if it proves willful misconduct or gross negligence; ordinary carelessness does not qualify.

Who has to prove gross negligence, the bank or the customer?

The bank. The Supreme Court said so again in two 2026 rulings (Rol No. 55.219-2025 and Rol No. 14.463-2026): in fraud cases the rules on burden of proof work differently from the general rules, and the bank is released from the refund only if it proves the user's willful misconduct or gross negligence. Requiring customers to prove their own diligence shifts that burden the wrong way.

Is clicking a link in a text message gross negligence?

Not by itself. In Rol No. 55.219-2025, decided on October 6, 2026, the customer had clicked a link in a text message but denied handing over any passwords or the security grid card. The Supreme Court faulted the appeals court for resting negligence on the click alone while ignoring the rest of the customer's account, and reinstated the dismissal of the bank's claim.

When does the bank win a gross negligence lawsuit in Chile?

When it proves more than the customer's involvement in the transaction. In the published rulings, banks have won where the customer typed credentials into a fake website and a technical report ruled out any failure on the bank's side, where the customer let someone else use the card and passwords, or where the customer noticed something wrong and took days to react, without asking for the payment methods to be blocked. In the San Carlos local police court, 3 of 90 claims succeeded.

Why do these cases reach the Supreme Court through a recurso de queja?

Because in local police court cases the final judgment can be appealed only to the Court of Appeals, and Law No. 18,287 rules out cassation. Against the appellate ruling, what remains is the recurso de queja, a disciplinary appeal against the judges that requires a serious fault or abuse. Even when it denies the queja, the Supreme Court may set the judgment aside on its own motion under its disciplinary powers, as it did in the Banco Itaú case.

What should you do if your bank sues you after a scam?

Do not let service of process go unanswered, and build the defense on the full facts. The bank complaint, the affidavit and the police report should tell the whole story, including what helps the customer. In the lawsuit, ask for the bank's records: alerts generated, IP addresses, devices and one-time passcode delivery. The deadline to appeal the local court's judgment is five days.